Tag Archives: billionaires vinegar

Broadbent’s Revenge

Loyal reader(s?) may remember my review of the book The Billionaire’s Vinegar.  As a follow up to the story I saw that the venerable British wine critic Micheal Broadbent settled his libel and defamation suit against Random House, the publisher of the book.  The book was less than flattering to Mr. Broadbent.  The amount of the monetary settlement is undisclosed,  but Random House issued an apology and has agreed not to distribute the book any more in the United Kingdom.  The New York Times story can be found here.  Decanter (which he writes for) had a different take on it but did say that he was going to celebrate with a magnum of 1990 Mouton while pondering whether to seek an injunction about the film based on the book.

Leave a comment

Filed under Reading, Wine

The Billionaire’s Vinegar

Continuing my posts on books I’ve been reading: I just finished up The Billionaire’s Vinegar: The Mystery of the World’s Most Expensive Wine by Benjamin Wallace (also available from FCPL).  It was an interesting, if a little dry at the beginning, read.   Briefly it tells the story of the wine market for rare old (18th and 19th Century) wines.  It focuses on a number of bottles sold by a German dealer to various individuals, including a billionaire, that were purported to be from Thomas Jefferson’s cellar in Paris.  I enjoyed the book especially the last part where it becomes  a detective story in trying to figure out the authenticity of the bottles.   The story sweeps up so many eminences in the field of wine:  Robert Parker, Michael Broadbent, and Jancis Robinson to name just a few.  It was fascinating to see how they became vested in the authenticity or inauthenticity in the bottles and  how some people turned a willful blind eye, or at least indifference, to the doubts about the bottles just so they could have bragging rights about tasting or owning such a bottle.  Like all good tales it ultimately is about much more than just wine: ego, pride, greed and other facets of human nature.  For someone who has a wine cellar for the sole purpose of keeping wine for drinking, it  struck me how these rarefied collectors bore about as much relationship to the average wine drinker  as big game hunting does to cooking.   Without spoiling the ending by posting here I’d love to know what you think.

Fred

Leave a comment

Filed under Reading, Wine